Cookie Exchange Recipes
This post may contain affiliate links.
Add some cheer to your holiday season by grabbing a few friends and making any of these sweet-enough-for-Santa cookie exchange recipes! A little holiday magic is sure to be found when you crank up the carols, make a batch of classic sugar cookies, and enjoy a little eggnog. Maybe you prefer a traditional chocolate chip cookie with a tall glass of milk? I’ve got you covered with the round-up below.
1
Gingerbread Thumbprint Cookies
These Gingerbread Thumbprint Cookies marry warm cinnamon and ginger with sweet molasses and are filled with a decadent white chocolate filling for an unconventional twist. They are so soft and so easy to make. You’ll want to whip up a big batch for all of your holiday gatherings.
Check out this recipe
2
Peanut Butter Reindeer Cookies
If you’re looking for something fun and festive, you won’t be able to resist my Peanut Butter Reindeer Cookies! Grab the kids and transform classic peanut butter cookies into adorable reindeer with pretzels and your favorite candies. They are so easy to make, even your kids can do it! These are ideal for a fun family evening.
Check out this recipe
3
Grinch Cookies
My Grinch Cookies are festive in green and red, making them a vibrant addition to any cookie exchange. Perfectly sweet, but not overpowering, they come together in under an hour, which means you can have a plate of adorable cookies done in no time!
Check out this recipe
4
Chocolate Crinkles
Classic Chocolate Crinkle Cookies are a delicious, cakelike cookie with a fudgy center coated in powdered sugar. They are nostalgic and full of chocolate flavor. Your cookie crew with love them.
Check out this recipe
5
Best Ever Chocolate Chip Cookies
There’s nothing better than a classic, and these chocolate chip cookies will not disappoint! You’ll love this no-frills, beloved recipe, which is sure to become a new family favorite at your house.
Check out this recipe
6
Cake Mix Christmas Cookies
Cake mix, to make a cookie? Yes! These festive, colorful cookies start with a boxed cake mix and come together in about 25 minutes. They are the perfect shortcut cookie recipe when you’re crunched for time, but aren’t lacking in flavor or softness.
Check out this recipe
7
Christmas Sugar Cookie
My crisp Christmas Sugar Cookies are a classic you must have in your recipe box! You only need a few basic ingredients to make these crisp, cut-out cookies. They are great for both Christmas and beyond.
Check out this recipe
Save The Recipe!
Add your email below and we’ll send it straight to your inbox+ you’ll receive all our newest recipes
8
DoubleTree Chocolate Chip Cookie Recipe
This copycat recipe is inspired by the now-famous chocolate chip cookies guests receive upon check-in. A bit more involved than a classic chocolate chip cookie, these are worth the extra prep time, and your guests will want your recipe! They are the perfect bakery-style treat at home.
Check out this recipe
9
Gingerbread Drops (Molasses Crinkle Cookies)
These crinkle-style drop cookies are cozy and require minimal effort to make. They are soft, moist, and flavored with pantry staples ginger and molasses. Don’t love a drop cookie? The dough is versatile enough to make a roll and cut version as well.
10
Old Fashioned Chewy Peanut Butter Cookies
These Old Fashioned Chewy Peanut Butter Cookies are soft peanut butter cookies that are full peanut butter flavor. Made with simple ingredients and perfect for a picnic or as a lunch box snack.
Check out this recipe
11
Christmas Meringue Cookies
Christmas meringue cookies are light and airy cookies that are as festive as they are tasty, Whipped egg whites are flavored and baked for a perfect Christmas cookie.
Check out this recipe
12
Teddy Bear Cookies
These adorable teddy bear cookies are the perfect treat for kids’ birthday parties, baby showers, or school events. Easy cookies made with 3 simple ingredients and so cute! Kids can make these too.
Check out this recipe
13
Lemon Shortbread Cookies
These light and zesty Lemon shortbread cookies are perfect for warm weather gatherings or cozy tea time. A quick, no-fuss recipe that delivers big lemon flavor. So easy to make with simple ingredients.
Check out this recipe
14
Santa Cookies
These festive Santa Cookies are so easy to make with store-bought Nutter Butter Cookies
Check out this recipe
15
Reindeer Cookies
These simple reindeer cookies are a fun holiday food idea! Reindeer-themed treats are always a hit at the dessert table and will bring a smile to guests' faces!
Check out this recipe